Adam Smith Helps Win $6M Rockdale County Verdict for Child Burned at Summer Camp

Law.com Covers a $6 Million Rockdale County Verdict for a Child Burned at Summer Camp

Adam P. Smith, a partner and trial attorney with Fried Goldberg, LLC, teamed with Cherise Challenger of Challenger Law Group to win a $6 million verdict for the family of an 8-year-old girl burned at a Conyers summer camp. The Rockdale County State Court jury placed full responsibility for her burn injuries on the camp and its staff.

Attorneys Adam P. Smith and Cherise Challenger
Adam P. Smith (left) and Cherise Challenger represented the family during a three-day jury trial in September.

Law.com's Daily Report covered the trial on October 27, 2026, including how the legal team kept the jury focused on what the child still lives with, rather than on a dispute over how she ended up in a classroom without an adult. Read the full Law.com article (PDF).

Key Takeaways From the Rockdale County Verdict

  • $6 Million Verdict – The jury awarded $3 million for past pain and suffering and $3 million for future pain and suffering after less than three hours of deliberations.
  • Full Responsibility on the Camp – Jurors placed all of the fault on Conyers Adventist Academy and its staff member, rejecting the argument that the child's own choices caused her injury.
  • A Rejected $1.5 Million Offer – The family offered to resolve the case for $1.5 million before trial, and the defense never offered more than $250,000.
  • Lasting Scars Drove the Award – The burns had healed, so the trial focused on how permanent scarring continues to affect a young girl's daily life.
  • Resolved After Trial – Defense counsel told Law.com the parties reached a confidential settlement after the jury returned its verdict.

What Happened at the Conyers Summer Camp

The girl was attending a summer camp at Conyers Adventist Academy in June 2024. According to the complaint, a staff member left the gym during the lunch period, leaving the campers there without any adult supervision. During that time, another camper spilled hot water onto the girl's back, causing severe burns and permanent scars.

Her mother filed suit three months later. Along with negligence and vicarious liability claims, the complaint raised a premises liability claim under O.C.G.A. § 51-3-1, which requires property owners to use ordinary care to keep their premises safe for the people they invite in. The family sought compensation for the girl's injuries, along with punitive damages.

Can a Camp Blame an 8-Year-Old for Her Own Injury?

That was the heart of the defense at trial. Its lawyers argued that staff used the reasonable care of an "average responsible parent," the standard Georgia applies to negligent supervision claims of this kind. They said a teacher sent the girl to get a paper towel, she went to a different classroom instead of returning to the gym, and a 15-year-old camp helper's soup container folded as it came out of the microwave.

In the defense's telling, the burn was an unforeseeable mix of a product failure and the child's own decision. Jurors didn't see it that way. Challenger told Law.com that jurors struggled to understand how responsibility could fall on 8-year-olds "for simply behaving like children." Here's how the two sides framed the key issues before the jury sided with the family on each one.

IssueThe Family's PositionThe Defense's Position
SupervisionA staff member left the campers alone in the gym during lunch.Staff used the care an "average responsible parent" would use.
Cause of the BurnThe lack of adult supervision allowed the spill to happen.An unexpected container failure and the child's decision not to return to the gym.
Future Pain and SufferingThe scars will affect her for years, and treatment decisions should be hers when she's older.No compensation, since she hadn't treated with a plastic surgeon.

Showing a Jury What Medical Bills Leave Out

The burns had healed physically by the time of trial, so the legal team's challenge was showing how the injury still shapes the girl's life. Rather than put her on the witness stand, Smith and Challenger played portions of the discovery deposition the defense had recorded. They paired it with a photo taken before the injury and a screenshot of her wearing a jean jacket in the Georgia heat of June to hide the scars on her back.

The defense asked the jury to award nothing for future pain and suffering because she hadn't seen a plastic surgeon. Smith explained that her mother faced an impossible choice, since more treatment could reinforce the idea that something is wrong with how her daughter looks, and it could make the marks worse. Her mother plans to let her make her own treatment decisions after she turns 18.

In closing, Smith asked jurors to value past pain and suffering at $200 per hour, about 20% of the more than $1,000 per hour the defense expert charged to come to trial. For future pain and suffering, he asked for $10 per hour. After less than three hours, the jury awarded $3 million for each.

Why a Rejected Settlement Offer Carries Weight in Georgia

Before trial, the family's attorneys offered to resolve the case for $1.5 million under O.C.G.A. § 9-11-68, Georgia's offer-of-settlement statute. According to Law.com, the defense refused to offer anything over $250,000.

That statute gives a rejected offer real consequences. When a defendant turns down a plaintiff's offer and the final judgment is more than 125% of that amount, the plaintiff can recover reasonable attorney's fees and litigation expenses from the date the offer was rejected. Here, the verdict came in at four times the family's offer. Defense counsel later told Law.com the parties reached a confidential settlement after trial.

Low Medical Bills Shouldn't Decide What a Child's Injury Is Worth

Smith represents people seriously injured in tractor-trailer, car, and premises liability accidents, and this verdict reflects a point he made to Law.com after trial. Medical expenses never tell the whole story, and a family shouldn't be afraid to try a case when the injury is real, even when the bills are low.

Our firm's verdicts and settlements show that same willingness to put serious injury cases in front of a jury when an insurance company won't offer fair value. When a child is hurt because adults weren't watching, the evidence about who was responsible, and the full effect of the injury, deserves the same careful preparation.

If your child was seriously hurt because a camp or school failed to supervise, talk with our attorneys about what happened during a free, confidential consultation. Plaintiff's attorneys may also reach our firm to discuss co-counsel or referral help on a serious injury case.

"I recently concluded a case with Fried Goldberg with Adam Smith as our attorney. I was immediately set at ease by Adam's vast knowledge and years of experience in the trucking industry. He knew EXACTLY what to do. He took care of my immediate needs, developed a plan for anticipated contingencies, and provided a realistic timeline going forward. His advice and counsel were invaluable. Fried Goldberg - and Adam Smith in particular - receive my highest possible endorsement." — W.L., ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Contact UsClick Here

    Contact Us
    Complete this form to connect with us or call us at 404.591.1800. Our team of experienced lawyers is dedicated to helping you. All consultations are confidential and cost you nothing.