XIV. Principles of Accident Reconstruction in Commercial Vehicle Cases
Previous Chapter: XIII. Other Types of Accidents Related to Commercial Vehicles
Next Chapter: XV. Cellphone Evidence
A. Skidmarks and Physical Evidence at the Scene
Because skidmarks disappear from the roadway within days of a collision, it is important to have the accident reconstructionist go to scene and preserve the physical evidence on the roadway within a week of the accident if possible.
The accident reconstructionist should take photos of all the marks and physical evidence left on the roadway and survey the scene in order to create a scale diagram of the area. If the accident occurred more than a month before the lawyer is retained in the case, there is no reason to rush to have the accident reconstructionist survey the scene unless the accident occurred in a construction zone where the layout of the area may change. After a month, there is no chance of the marks being present in the roadway unless it is a very rural and untraveled area.
B. Area of Impact
The area of impact is normally determined by the presence of a gouge mark. When two vehicles collide, one of the vehicles is normally pushed down causing a scuff mark or gouge mark as the metal frame digs into the asphalt.
If there is no gouge mark, then the next method of determining the area of impact is to look at the debris field. When two vehicles impact, there is normally a debris field of broken glass and metal in the area.
While it is not as definitive, the debris field can be used to locate the general area of impact between the vehicles.
C. Lights on the Vehicle
In nighttime collisions involving a disabled or slow-moving vehicle, there is often an issue as to whether to not the lights were on the vehicle that was struck by the tractor-trailer. If the vehicle has LED lights rather than normal halogen headlights, then there is no way to know if the lights were on at the time of the collision. However, halogen lights and electric bulbs (which are the typical lights used on a vehicle) have a filament that can be used to determine if the lights were on at the time of the collision. When the lights are on, the filament is warm and has the ability to stretch in a collision instead of breaking. If the filament is stretched, then the lights were on at the time of the collision. If the filament is cold and breaks in the collision, then the lights were off. The blinking of hazard lights are enough to warm the filaments and so the same rule is applicable to whether or not hazard lights were activated and blinking at the time of the collision. Your accident reconstructionist should photograph all the bulbs and filaments on the vehicle if there is an issue as to whether or not the lights were on at the time of the collision.
D. Electronic Control Module
The Electronic Control Module (ECM) is the “black box” of the tractor and should always be downloaded. The ECM data is so important that we have an entire section of the book dedicated to understanding the ECM data. Make sure your reconstructionist downloads the ECM or obtains a copy of the download from the defense side to interpret the data.
E. Airbag Module on Client’s Vehicle
While we always want to download the ECM from the tractor-trailer, it is also important to locate your client’s vehicle and download the airbag module. If the vehicle is equipped with an airbag module, there is a possibility that the collision could have activated the airbag module and recorded data for the seconds leading up to the collision. The airbag module can record the speed of the vehicle and whether or not the brakes were activated for up to 5 seconds.
Like with the ECM, the data from the airbag module has to be interpreted by the reconstructionist. The zero point on the airbag download does not necessarily mean the point of impact. The zero point is only where the airbag module first woke up and started recording data, and the reconstructionist needs to take into account the type of collision and the physical evidence at the scene to see where in the process that the airbag module would have woken up.
F. Speed and Distance Analysis
The speed of a vehicle can be calculated using the standard formula:
speed = the square root of 30 x distance x coefficient of friction.
The coefficient of friction represents the amount of friction on the roadway. The most accurate way to determine the coefficient of friction is to drag a sled on the roadway which records the amount of friction. However, it is generally accepted that highway asphalt has a coefficient of friction in the range of 0.70 to 0.75. Distance is the amount of distance that the vehicle travelled from the time of braking until it comes to a stop. Normally this is determined by the length of the skidmarks left by the vehicle. The speed analysis is only relevant if you cannot determine the vehicle’s speed from the download of the airbag module or the ECM. The electronic data is much more reliable than skidmark measurements and a speed analysis based on skidmarks.
G. Perception/Reaction Time
A reconstructionist should be able to use a speed and distance analysis along with perception/reaction time to determine where vehicles were at certain times prior to a collision and if there was sufficient time to take evasive maneuvers or avoid a collision. In a regular daytime scenario presented to a driver, a standard perception/reaction time is 1.5 seconds. The 1.5 seconds includes 1 second to see and perceive the danger and .5 seconds to move the foot to the brake and press it or to make an evasive maneuver. With a tractor-trailer driver, the perception reaction time is 1.75 seconds because there is a .25 second delay from when the brakes are pressed until the brakes actually engage on a tractor-trailer because of the air system that controls the brakes. A reconstructionist can determine where a tractor-trailer was prior to a collision by determining its speed prior to braking and moving the tractor-trailer backwards 1.75 seconds for perception/reaction time (for example at 55 mph that is 88 feet per second for a total of 154 feet). The importance of determining the location of vehicles prior to impact is to see if the truck driver was distracted so that he did not perceive and react to the danger in a reasonable manner (for example if the car was visible in the roadway for 1,000 but the truck driver did not perceive the vehicle until he was 500 feet from the vehicle, then there is a question as to why he did not see it sooner and slow down).
H. Re-Enactments and Simulations
Many accidents involve a tractor-trailer that is across the roadway either while making a turn or disabled for some reason. The claimant’s vehicle collides with the tractor- trailer because the claimant fails to see the tractor-trailer in time to avoid running into it. These types of accidents always involve issues of visibility, especially when the collision occurs at night. The primary defense is that the claimant should have been able to see and avoid colliding with the tractor-trailer if the claimant had been paying attention while driving. As a result, it is imperative to re-enact the collision so that the jury can visually understand that anyone in the claimant’s position would not have been able to recognize the tractor-trailer in time to take evasive action.
We performed a re-enactment of a collision where a tractor-trailer in a rural area was backing into a driveway when the claimant ran into the rear of the trailer which was in her lane of travel. By looking at the photographs of the re-enactment, it is evident that the tractor’s headlights gave the appearance to the claimant that the tractor-trailer was approaching the claimant in the opposite lane of travel, and that it was impossible to see the trailer in the roadway until the claimant was less than 80 feet away.
At 55 mph, the claimant traveled 88 feet in one second. Because a driver’s perception/reaction time is at least 2 seconds at night, the claimant had no chance to perceive and react to the trailer before she collided with it. The re-enactment was critical to explaining this issue to the jury.
Always consider a re-enactment of a nighttime driving accident.
Contact Our Tractor Trailer Accident Lawyers — Based in Atlanta
Request a copy of The Trucking Book
Please complete the form on this page to request a copy of our trucking book, Understanding Motor Carrier Claims, Sixth Edition. Or, should you like to request a consultation with one of our attorneys, please contact us.
The Truck Accident Attorneys
The Truck Accident Attorneys at Fried Goldberg LLC devote at least 75% of their caseload to representing the victims of accidents involving tractor trailers and other commercial vehicles. Our extensive experience with the laws governing the trucking industry is the reason we are routinely successful at taking on trucking companies when someone is seriously injured.
Get a Free Case Evaluation
The Truck Accident Attorneys
The Truck Accident Attorneys at Fried Goldberg LLC devote at least 95% of their caseload to representing the victims of accidents involving tractor trailers and other commercial vehicles. Our extensive experience with the laws governing the trucking industry is the reason we are routinely successful at taking on trucking companies when someone is seriously injured.
Table of Contents
Get a Free Case Evaluation
Use the form to send your message to a lawyer at our firm. One of our experienced attorneys is prepared to speak with you. Consultations are free and confidential.